
On October 13, 2026, prosecutors narrowed Sara Duterte’s impeachment. They withdrew three of four articles. Only the charge of unexplained wealth remains. The court then confined the defense to that charge. The defense can no longer answer the others.
This essay argues that the ruling was unfair. It draws on John Rawls and Amartya Sen. The unfairness falls on Duterte, the public, and accountability. Later sections cover protest, objections, and Mindanao’s view.
Rawls’ A Theory of Justice appeared in 1971. He called his view justice as fairness. Fair rules are chosen behind a veil of ignorance.
Choosers do not know their class or talents. They also do not know their future roles. Rawls derived two principles from this thought experiment. First, everyone gets equal basic liberties, including due process. Second, inequalities must benefit the least advantaged.
Rawls also distinguished kinds of procedural justice. Criminal trials are imperfect procedural justice in his terms. No procedure guarantees the right verdict every time. Fair procedures minimize error by hearing both sides.
Sen’s The Idea of Justice appeared in 2009. He challenged Rawls’s search for perfectly just institutions. Sen called that approach transcendental institutionalism.
He proposed a comparative, realization-focused approach instead. Sen asks which real option reduces injustice more. Outcomes and actual lives matter as much as rules. Perfect justice is unnecessary for spotting remediable injustice. We can fix clear wrongs without an ideal blueprint.
Sen also stresses public reasoning and open debate. He borrows Adam Smith’s impartial spectator. That spectator judges from outside any local interest. Fair processes must withstand that outside scrutiny.
On October 13, prosecutors dropped Articles I, III, and IV. Those covered confidential funds, bribery, and threats against Marcos. Presiding Officer Chiz Escudero accepted the withdrawal.
The trial now rests on Article II, unexplained wealth. Escudero limited the defense to evidence on Article II. Articles I and IV were dropped with prejudice. Duterte therefore cannot rebut those charges in court. The trial resumes on November 9.
Prosecutors had already presented much of their case. Three witnesses testified on threats, and eleven on funds. Bribery’s five listed witnesses never testified. The defense raised due process and mistrial concerns.
Imagine choosing trial rules behind the veil. You might become the accused, prosecutor, or citizen. As the accused, you would demand a right to answer.
That right is a basic liberty under Rawls’s first principle. Fourteen witnesses spoke against Duterte on the dropped articles. Senator-judges heard every word of that testimony. Duterte now cannot offer a single witness in reply. The record is now permanently one-sided.
Imperfect procedures must reduce error wherever they can. One-sided records raise the risk of wrongful judgment. Testimony cannot be unheard, even after charges vanish. It can still color how judges weigh Article II.
The people suffer under Rawls’s view too. He insists on the fair value of political liberty. Citizens deserve elections informed by fully tested facts.
Untested accusations distort the 2028 choice either way. Accountability also loses under a Rawlsian lens. Dropping with prejudice ends these questions in impeachment. Guilt or innocence on threats may never be settled. That leaves a permanent gap in the public record.
Sen would compare the actual options available. Option one: the defense answers all aired evidence. Option two: the defense answers only Article II. The first reduces injustice more, at little cost.
Sen’s impartial spectator would see a lopsided record. One side spoke for weeks on three articles. The other side must now stay silent on them.
Public reasoning suffers as well. Filipinos heard grave accusations, including an assassination threat. Those claims now circulate without any verdict. Malacañang itself questioned the fate of the bribery evidence. Accountability needs claims tested, judged, and closed.
Abandoned charges leave accusers and accused both unvindicated. Legitimacy matters too in Sen’s framework. Four pro-Duterte senators are absent, so 14 votes convict. The Senate also lowered the conviction threshold last month.
Narrowed charges plus lower thresholds look strategic. Perceived unfairness erodes trust in institutions. Sen would treat that erosion as real injustice.
If the ruling stands, the defense could justifiably withdraw. Participation would lend legitimacy to a one-sided record. Withdrawal would register protest for the historical record. Minority senators could justifiably refuse to sit too. Senator Robin Padilla has already floated a boycott.
Judges should refuse to ratify proceedings they consider unfair. Rawls allows principled dissent when basic liberties suffer. Sen values public protest as part of public reasoning. Both views make room for such a stand.
At minimum, the court should partly reverse its ruling. The defense should answer Articles I and IV. Prosecution testimony entered the record on exactly those articles.
Bribery can stay excluded, since its witnesses never testified. This remedy is modest and proportionate. It restores balance while leaving dropped charges dead. The prosecution loses nothing it legitimately gained. Both Rawls and Sen would likely endorse it.
Defenders of the ruling make serious points. Prosecutors normally decide which charges they pursue. Dismissal with prejudice protects Duterte from repeat trials. Rebutting dropped charges could add weeks to proceedings.
Senators can be instructed to ignore dropped evidence. A Rawlsian could say fewer charges favor the accused. A Sen-style comparison might value a timely verdict.
Delay has its own costs for governance. These arguments deserve weight in any fair assessment. Dropping charges is defensible under both theories. Silencing rebuttal after testimony aired is much harder. Fairness requires letting Duterte answer what judges heard.
Mindanao is the Duterte family’s political home. Rodrigo Duterte became its first president in 2016. Davao City has been Duterte-run for decades. Many Mindanawons see Sara Duterte as their own.
Many will read this ruling through older grievances. They have long resented what they call Imperial Manila. A Manila Senate silencing their daughter fits that story.
Rodrigo Duterte’s ICC arrest in 2025 deepened that hurt. Many supporters called it a betrayal by Malacañang. This impeachment may look like a second blow. The one-sided record will feed claims of persecution. Rawls’s veil makes their worry easy to understand.
Mindanao is far from one voice, though. Bangsamoro communities have their own history with Manila. Some Mindanawons welcome scrutiny of Duterte power. Lumad and progressive groups often criticized Duterte rule.
The political stakes are high. A tainted verdict could harden the Mindanao bloc. That bloc delivered huge Duterte margins in 2022. It does not matter if Sara Duterte is convicted and disqualified. Her vote will transfer to Baste Duterte and more.
It could shape the 2028 presidential race decisively. Talk of Mindanao separation may also resurface. Rodrigo Duterte floated secession as recently as 2024. A fairer process would deny that talk any fuel. Sen’s impartial spectator would weigh these regional effects.
National unity depends on processes losers can accept. Mindanawons must be able to trust the verdict. Whatever it is, fairness must be visible. Only then can accountability help unite the nation.
I may want Duterte found guilty on some charges. I may want her permanently barred from public office. Becoming as corrupt as the accused is the wrong path. The means never justifies the end.
Unfair means turn accusers into the monster they fight. Rawls asks what rules we would choose blindly. Sen asks which real option leaves less injustice. Both questions point toward a fuller defense. The people deserve answers, and Duterte deserves a hearing.
Mindanao deserves a verdict it can respect. The whole nation deserves the same.
Accountability depends on all of these. Let us get the process right.
Originally published in MindaNews on October 14, 2026
